Newsreal
Last night I watched Sky News' live report from Fatboy Slim's
beachside party for 20,000 paying guests. However, even without the
TV, from my armchair I could hear the music. It wasn't intrusive and I
didn't mind. Much worse are the regular booming firework displays from
the pier. Window panes wobble in their frames. For a few moments, it's
unclear what the hell is going on. Then there's silence save for a few
flapping seagulls. Tim Footman relates a similar experience in Bangkok
over the weekend. He hears news of the bombs.
I send a mass email, to say I'm OK, hope you are too. Half a dozen
bounce back. Out of office. Happy New Year. Back Tuesday. Maybe. A
firework goes off outside, and I jump, but just a little bit.
Someone's rigged up a sound system. Heavy bass. I look out. You'd
never know there was anything wrong. Just like the coup, and the
tsunami before that. The dogs bark, but the dogs always bark.
Death is elsewhere. The novelty of being so close to the horror and
glamour of a news event prompted a familiar question. How close is so
close?
We watch Saddam experiencing the injustice he inflicted upon so many
others, the same footage showed again and again as if in search of
something hidden, and it's not enough. We want to know how and what he
felt. The ghost of the fact is the story with which we're preoccupied.
The silence broken by dogs and seagulls, and the repetition of the
search, remains under-explored in fiction, and is always under threat.
Kafka turned towards it by turning away.
The fact that there is fear, grief and desolation in the world is
something he understands, but even this only in so far as these are
vague, general feelings, just grazing the surface. All other
feelings he denies; what we call by that name is for him mere
illusion, fairy-tale, reflection of our knowledge and our memory.
How could it be otherwise, he thinks, since after all our feelings
can never catch up with the actual events, let alone overtake them.
We experience the feelings only before and after the actual event,
which flits by at an elemental, incomprehensible speed; they are
dream-like fictions, restricted to ourselves alone. We live in the
stillness of midnight, and experience sunrise and sunset by turning
towards the east and the west.
Yet when an author wanders into this space, the critics hunt in packs.
Joseph O'Neill joins those rejecting Franz Bascombe's latest spectral
appearance in Richard Ford's The Lay of the Land. He says the final
volume is unconvincing compared to the two previous.
Those books ... are anchored by very real familial misfortunes (the
death of a child, the disintegration of a marriage, the troubles of
an anguished fifteen-year-old son) that Frank, anomie
notwithstanding, cannot help but humanly experience and
communicate. The Lay of the Land, it transpires, has no comparable
anchor - and this is where the trouble starts.
The trouble for O'Neill is that it doesn't ring true.
Thus it struck me, about a third of the way through, that Frank
Bascombe repeatedly says, does, and thinks stuff that nobody would,
not even Frank Bascombe. I ended up - like Kingsley Amis reading
Virginia Woolf - muttering to myself, No he didn't; no, that isn't
what he thought; no, that's just what she didnt say. [sic]
Well, yes, Kingsley Amis, Virginia Woolf! In my own apparently
stillborn review, I wanted to make this aspect of the novel the real
tragedy; not the deaths, break-ups and troubles - so very real that
O'Neill's forgotten they're fictional - but that, despite Frank's
extraordinary articulacy, his readers are in the same alienated
position as his ex-wife and children. Even as the news increasingly
resembles genre fiction, a literary novel is not the news.
at 5:42 PM 0 comments
February 2007 December 2006 Home
Subscribe to: Posts (Atom)
My Shelfari Bookshelf
Shelfari: Book reviews on your book blog
email address
Please contact me, Stephen Mitchelmore, at steve dot mitchelmore at
gmail dot com
Literary and other links
* British Literary Blogs
* ReadySteadyBook blog
* Spurious
* Book Depository: Editor's Corner
* The Literary Saloon
* The Existence Machine
* The Reading Experience
* Scarecrow Comment
* Guardian Books Blog
* The Quarterly Conversation
* KCRW Bookworm
* BookForum
* wood s lot
* Mountain 7
* Todd Colby's Glee Farm
* Three per cent
* Tales from the Reading Room
* The Bibliophilic Blogger
* The Penguin Blog
* TLS: Peter Stothard
* Mary Beard
* Nomadics: Pierre Joris
* Lenin's Tomb
* Dispatches from Zembla
* Waggish
More literary blogs
* Jonathan Swift's Journal to Stella
* The Best of New Writing on the Web
* John Self's Asylum
* Anatomy of Melancholy
* The Truth About Lies
* Nigel Beale: Nota Bene
* Thomas McGonigle's ABC of Reading
* Vertigo: Collecting WG Sebald
* Un Arbre dans la Ville
* The Wooden Spoon
* The Joyful Knowing
* The Reader Onliine
* In Abstentia Out
* Jacob Russell's Barking Dog
* eNotes Book Blog
* Diderot's Diary
Book buying
* *Steve's Wishlist*
* The Book Depository - Cheap books and free delivery
* Booksprice - price comparisons
* Abebooks
Favoured author sites
* Maurice Blanchot
* Thomas Bernhard (German equivalent)
* Gabriel Josipovici
* Peter Handke (German equivalent)
* Princeton Dante Project
* Proust: Temps Perdu
* The Kafka Project
* Charlotte Mandell
* Noam Chomsky
* John Pilger
Blog Archive
* February 2008 (1)
* January 2008 (10)
* December 2007 (26)
* November 2007 (28)
* October 2007 (16)
* September 2007 (24)
* August 2007 (15)
* July 2007 (17)
* June 2007 (11)
* May 2007 (23)
* April 2007 (11)
* March 2007 (24)
* February 2007 (27)
* January 2007 (21)
* December 2006 (9)
* November 2006 (24)
* October 2006 (21)
* September 2006 (19)
* August 2006 (15)
* July 2006 (33)
* June 2006 (17)
* May 2006 (24)
* April 2006 (17)
* March 2006 (18)
* February 2006 (15)
* January 2006 (8)
* December 2005 (8)
* November 2005 (10)
* October 2005 (7)
* September 2005 (14)
* August 2005 (14)
* July 2005 (8)
* June 2005 (15)
* May 2005 (11)
* April 2005 (13)
* March 2005 (9)
* February 2005 (7)
* January 2005 (16)
* December 2004 (2)
* November 2004 (4)
No comments:
Post a Comment